Figueroa v. John Doe

September 10, 2026
 / 
seva firm

Figueroa v. John Doe: Court of Appeals Holds the Rental Vehicle’s Insurer Has Priority for an Uber Driver’s PIP Benefits

By Pratheep Sevanthinathan, Esq. The Seva Law Firm

Case: Lenadanielle Figueroa v. John Doe, No. 374996 (Mich. Ct. App. Sept. 10, 2026) (Unpublished)

Court: Michigan Court of Appeals Panel: M. J. Kelly, P.J., and O’Brien and Lievense, JJ.

Decision: Affirmed — Per Curiam

Lower Court: Wayne Circuit Court, Case No. 24-001143-NI

Read the full opinion here

  1. Introduction

The Michigan Court of Appeals has clarified an important priority rule for rideshare drivers seeking personal protection insurance benefits. In Figueroa v. John Doe, the Court held that an Uber driver who was injured while driving a vehicle rented specifically for rideshare work had to seek PIP benefits from the insurer of that rental vehicle under MCL 500.3114(2), even though she was logged out of the Uber app, had no passenger, and was driving home when the collision occurred.

The decision emphasizes that the inquiry is not limited to what the driver was doing at the precise moment of the crash. Instead, courts examine the vehicle’s primary use and whether transporting passengers is a primary component of the driver’s overall business or activity.

  1. Facts

Lenadanielle Figueroa rented a vehicle from Hertz on September 5, 2023, through a program that Hertz operated with Uber to provide vehicles to rideshare drivers. The rental agreement included insurance coverage.

On October 20, 2023, another driver made a U-turn, struck Figueroa’s rental vehicle, and fled the scene. At the time of the collision, Figueroa had no passengers, was logged out of the Uber app, and was driving home.

Rather than seeking coverage under the rental agreement, Figueroa applied for no-fault benefits through the Michigan Assigned Claims Plan. Her claim was assigned to Farmers Insurance Exchange. Farmers investigated the claim and denied benefits. Figueroa then filed suit seeking PIP benefits.

Farmers moved for summary disposition, arguing that Hertz’s insurer had higher priority under MCL 500.3114(2) because the rental vehicle was operated in the business of transporting passengers. The Wayne Circuit Court agreed and dismissed the claim against Farmers.

  1. Issues

The central issue was whether the rental vehicle qualified as a “motor vehicle operated in the business of transporting passengers” under MCL 500.3114(2) when Figueroa was logged out of the Uber app, had no passenger, and was driving home at the moment of the accident.

The Court also addressed Figueroa’s argument that the vehicle was not a “transportation network company vehicle” at the time of the crash because she was offline. The Court had to determine whether that statutory language controlled the priority analysis for an injured operator, rather than a passenger.

  1. Holding

The Court of Appeals affirmed summary disposition for Farmers. It held that Figueroa was the operator of a vehicle operated in the business of transporting passengers and therefore had to obtain PIP benefits from the insurer of the rental vehicle under MCL 500.3114(2).

First, the Court explained that the statute’s specific provision concerning passengers in transportation network company vehicles applies only to passengers. Because Figueroa was the vehicle’s operator, her claim was governed by the first sentence of MCL 500.3114(2). Her online or offline status did not decide the issue.

Second, the Court applied the “primary purpose/incidental nature” test. That test asks whether transporting passengers is the primary purpose for which the vehicle is used and whether passenger transportation is a primary, rather than incidental, part of the operator’s business or activity.

Figueroa’s own testimony established both elements. She rented the vehicle through the Hertz-Uber program; the vast majority of its time and mileage was devoted to transporting Uber passengers; she drove for Uber approximately five hours each weekday; she used the vehicle only minimally for personal purposes; and Uber driving was her only job and source of income at the time.

Those facts established that the vehicle’s primary purpose was passenger transportation and that transporting passengers was the primary component of Figueroa’s business. Consequently, the rental vehicle’s insurer—not Farmers through the Assigned Claims Plan—was responsible for any PIP benefits owed.

  1. Conclusion

The Court of Appeals affirmed the dismissal of Figueroa’s claim against Farmers. Even though she was offline, had no passenger, and was driving home when the collision occurred, the rental vehicle remained a vehicle operated in the business of transporting passengers because of its primary use and the nature of Figueroa’s work. Under MCL 500.3114(2), the insurer of that vehicle occupied the highest priority for her PIP claim.

Because that conclusion resolved the appeal, the Court declined to address Farmers’ alternative basis for summary disposition.

  1. What Does This Mean for Our Clients?

This decision matters to Uber, Lyft, taxi, limousine, and other drivers who use vehicles primarily to transport passengers. Here are the key takeaways:

Being offline at the moment of a crash does not necessarily change PIP priority. A driver may still be considered the operator of a vehicle used in the business of transporting passengers even while logged out of a rideshare app, traveling without a passenger, or driving home.

Courts look at the vehicle’s overall primary use. Important evidence can include why the vehicle was acquired or rented, how much of its mileage is devoted to rideshare work, the extent of its personal use, the driver’s work schedule, and whether rideshare driving is the driver’s principal source of income.

Operators and passengers are treated differently under MCL 500.3114(2). The statutory exception for a passenger in a transportation network company vehicle does not govern an injured driver. Identifying whether the claimant was an operator or passenger is essential before determining which insurer has priority.

Choosing the wrong insurer can jeopardize a claim. Michigan’s no-fault priority rules are technical, and a claim submitted through the Michigan Assigned Claims Plan may fail when another insurer has higher statutory priority. Promptly identifying every potentially responsible policy—including coverage attached to a rental or rideshare vehicle—is critical.

If you were injured while driving for Uber, Lyft, or another passenger transportation service, contact The Seva Law Firm. We can identify the insurer responsible for your PIP benefits and protect your claim before priority disputes create costly delays.

Pratheep Sevanthinathan is the owner and managing attorney of The Seva Law Firm, located at 100 W. Big Beaver Rd, Suite 500, Troy, MI 48084. He can be reached at (248) 385-5704.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

Michigan Court of Appeals: An Uber driver injured in a hit-and-run had to seek PIP benefits from the insurer of her Hertz rental vehicle—not Farmers through the Michigan Assigned Claims Plan—even though she was offline, had no passenger, and was driving home when the crash occurred.

In Figueroa v. John Doe, the driver rented the vehicle through a Hertz-Uber program. She testified that the vast majority of its time and mileage was used for Uber, she drove about five hours each weekday, personal use was limited, and Uber was her only job and income.

The Court applied MCL 500.3114(2) and the “primary purpose/incidental nature” test. Because passenger transportation was the vehicle’s primary use and the primary component of the driver’s business, the rental vehicle’s insurer had priority. The special statutory language for passengers in transportation network company vehicles did not control because Figueroa was the operator.

Key takeaway: Logging out of a rideshare app does not necessarily change which insurer owes PIP benefits. Courts examine the vehicle’s overall use, and submitting a claim to the wrong insurer can put benefits at risk.

Injured while driving for Uber, Lyft, or another transportation service? Contact The Seva Law Firm at (248) 385-5704 for help identifying the responsible insurer and protecting your no-fault claim.