Simmon v. State Farm

October 14, 2026
 / 
seva firm

Simmon v. State Farm: Court of Appeals Addresses IME Testimony, Vehicle-Damage Opinions, and Proof of Causation in a PIP Case

By Pratheep Sevanthinathan, Esq. The Seva Law Firm

Case: Omika Simmon v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company, No. 373218 (Mich. Ct. App. Oct. 13, 2026) (Unpublished)

Court: Michigan Court of Appeals

Panel: Korobkin, P.J., and Rick and Maldonado, JJ.

Decision: Affirmed — Per Curiam

Lower Court: Wayne Circuit Court, Case No. 22-006983-NF

Read the full opinion here

  1. Introduction

In Simmon v. State Farm, the Michigan Court of Appeals addressed three recurring issues in first-party no-fault litigation: whether the specialty-matching requirements for an insurance medical examination (IME) also restrict the examiner’s testimony at trial, whether a physician may characterize the severity of a collision from a vehicle photograph, and whether disputed medical bills matter when the jury finds that the claimed injury was not caused by the motor vehicle accident.

The Court affirmed a no-cause verdict for State Farm. It held that MCL 500.3151 governs the qualifications of a physician who conducts an IME, but does not itself bar that physician from later testifying at trial. The Court also held that the orthopedic examiner’s opinion that a photograph suggested an “extremely minor” event was inadmissible, although the error was harmless. Finally, the Court declined to decide whether certain physical-therapy bills were compensable because the jury’s causation finding independently defeated the claim.

  1. Facts

Omika Simmon was stopped at a red light in August 2019 when another vehicle caused a chain-reaction collision, pushing the car behind her into the rear of her sedan. Simmon testified that she was jerked forward and struck her knee on the steering wheel. Although she initially felt no pain and her vehicle required no repairs, she developed soreness in her shoulders, neck, knee, and lower back the next day.

Simmon had experienced some back, knee, and shoulder pain before the accident, but testified that her symptoms worsened afterward and that she had not previously suffered neck pain. She treated with several providers, including a chiropractor, a pain-management physician, and an orthopedic surgeon. She received chiropractic treatment, injections, diagnostic testing, trigger-point impedance imaging, and other care.

State Farm initially paid PIP benefits. In June 2020, orthopedic surgeon Paul Drouillard, D.O., examined Simmon at State Farm’s request. He concluded that she had not sustained a new injury or aggravated a preexisting condition in the collision. State Farm stopped paying benefits on June 19, 2020.

Simmon later sued for PIP benefits associated with chiropractic care, physical therapy, and medical mileage. At trial, her treating doctors linked her conditions to the crash, while Dr. Drouillard testified that the accident caused no new injury and required no additional treatment. The jury found that Simmon had sustained an accidental bodily injury or aggravation of a preexisting injury, but found that it did not arise out of the ownership, operation, maintenance, or use of a motor vehicle. The trial court entered a judgment of no cause of action for State Farm.

  1. Issues

The Court of Appeals considered three principal questions:

  1. Whether MCL 500.3151 barred Dr. Drouillard’s trial testimony because he did not practice in the same specialties as the providers whose later treatment was at issue.
  2. Whether Dr. Drouillard could testify, based on a photograph showing no visible vehicle damage, that the collision appeared to be an “extremely minor event.”
  3. Whether the trial court improperly granted State Farm a partial directed verdict on physical-therapy bills allegedly lacking the prescription required by MCL 500.3107b.
  4. Holding

The Court first held that MCL 500.3151 did not prohibit Dr. Drouillard from testifying. That statute imposes licensing, specialty, and board-certification requirements on physicians who conduct examinations requested by no-fault insurers. Its language does not establish a separate rule governing the admissibility of testimony at trial. The Court contrasted that statute with Michigan’s medical-malpractice expert statute, MCL 600.2169, which expressly regulates who may give expert testimony, and with MCL 500.3153(e), which expressly permits exclusion of testimony when an examining physician fails or refuses to provide a required report.

The Court next held that Dr. Drouillard’s testimony about the vehicle photograph was inadmissible. As an orthopedic surgeon, he was not qualified to give an expert accident-reconstruction opinion connecting visible vehicle damage to injury. The specific statement at issue—his observation that the photograph suggested an extremely minor event—was treated as lay opinion, but it still was not helpful in deciding a fact at issue and was therefore irrelevant.

Even so, the Court found the error harmless. The jury could view the photograph itself; the challenged testimony was brief and was not emphasized in closing argument; and one of Simmon’s doctors countered any implication that minimal vehicle damage necessarily meant minimal bodily injury. Given the complete trial record, the Court was not persuaded that the statement more likely than not affected the verdict.

Finally, the Court declined to decide whether the partial directed verdict concerning physical-therapy bills was erroneous. Because the jury’s causation finding remained intact, Simmon could not recover those expenses regardless of whether the therapy otherwise satisfied statutory requirements. Any error concerning those bills was therefore harmless.

  1. Conclusion

The Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment of no cause of action for State Farm. The decision confirms that MCL 500.3151’s specialty-matching provisions regulate an insurer-requested medical examination, but do not automatically determine whether the examiner may testify at trial. It also confirms that a medical witness’s commentary about collision severity from photographs remains subject to Michigan’s ordinary evidence rules. Most importantly, the case illustrates that causation remains an essential element of a PIP claim: even proof of injury and treatment will not establish entitlement to benefits unless the claimant proves that the injury arose from the use of a motor vehicle.

  1. What Does This Mean for Our Clients?

An IME statute is not the same as a trial-testimony rule. A challenge to an insurer’s medical witness must account for the precise language of MCL 500.3151 as well as the Michigan Rules of Evidence. The fact that an examiner’s specialty differs from a later treating provider’s specialty does not, standing alone, exclude the examiner’s testimony.

Doctors cannot automatically act as accident-reconstruction experts. A medical degree does not qualify a witness to infer collision severity or injury causation from photographs. When an insurer’s doctor ventures outside medicine, counsel should examine whether the opinion is relevant, helpful, and supported by appropriate expertise.

An evidentiary error must also be prejudicial to justify a new trial. The Court agreed that the vehicle-photo testimony should not have been admitted, but still affirmed because the statement was brief, cumulative of what jurors could see, and countered by other testimony. Preserving an objection is essential, but an appeal must also explain how the error likely changed the outcome.

Causation can decide the entire PIP claim. The jury found an injury or aggravation, yet rejected the required connection to motor-vehicle use. That finding made the dispute over particular therapy bills irrelevant. Medical records, treatment, and proof that services were reasonable and necessary are not enough without persuasive evidence tying the condition and expenses to the accident.

If your insurer has stopped paying no-fault benefits after an IME or is disputing whether your treatment was caused by a crash, contact The Seva Law Firm. These cases often turn on the medical evidence, the scope of expert testimony, and careful proof of causation.

Pratheep Sevanthinathan is the owner and managing attorney of The Seva Law Firm, located at 100 W. Big Beaver Rd, Suite 500, Troy, MI 48084. He can be reached at (248) 385-5704.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes.